One of the strong influences on my novel The Spanish Patriot was learning about the American colonists who did not wish to separate from Britain during the revolution and civil war of the late 1700s. From what I’d learned in school, I assumed there were maybe a few grump-headed Loyalists, some of whom joined the British to fight against the rebels (Benedict Arnold!), but then after peace was declared everyone quickly fell back into happy coexistence.
Not a sliver, but some 15-20 percent of all the white people in the colonies were Loyalists, also called Tories or Royalists. In fact, according to Robert M. Calhoon in A Companion to the American Revolution:
Approximately half the colonists of European ancestry tried to avoid involvement in the struggle—some of them deliberate pacifists, others recent immigrants, and many more simple apolitical folk. The patriots received active support from perhaps 40 to 45 percent of the white populace, and at most no more than a bare majority. — p 235
Not all loyalists were white Europeans, either. Thousands of slaves escaped to British lines, especially after Lord Dunmore’s “Emancipation Proclamation” in November 1775. Dunmore, fighting to hold the power of his position as royal governor of Virginia and bolster his 300-man army, declared all revolutionaries traitors to the Crown and promised freedom for slaves of American revolutionaries who left their owners and joined the royal forces. From 800 to 2,000 slaves of all ages and genders are thought to have joined with Dunmore. Some 300 men were enlisted into what was called Dunmore’s Ethiopian Regiment; others served in guerrilla units and other services. Later some would form the Black Pioneers mulitary unit, including Henry Washington, who had fled the plantation run by George and Martha Washington.
In 1779, British General Sir Henry Clinton issued the Philipsburg Proclamation, which freed slaves owned by revolutionaries throughout the rebel states, even if they did not enlist in the British Army. Perhaps as many as 100,000 slaves in total escaped from rebel areas during the years of civil war. (Native American groups, at first mainly neutral in the conflict, also eventually chose one side or the other, with painful repercussions.)
For my fictional Wakefield family, the choice of which side to take was tough. As printers who held the contract with the Virginia government, they would have made their living producing proclamations, forms, and other official documents, though they also took jobwork like blank forms, books and almanacs, theater announcements, and, of course, their Gazette, a weekly newspaper. Their newspaper, like most others, printed mostly international and national news; not much local news except advertisements and official announcements. Challenging royal authority could lose them their printer’s license.
But people with printing presses could be great mouthpieces for calls for change and revolution; already shops in more northern colonies were writing what could be called sedition.Jordan and Mary Wakefield in Williamsburg felt great pressure to call for revolution, but to do so meant their business would fail. It was not clear if the revolutionaries would pay for the jobwork they wanted. However strongly you felt you wanted to stay neutral and work through peaceful means, it was growing clear, though, that if you were not with them you were against them. As Catholics, who already had left England because of persecution, the family also did not find these patriots any more accepting of freedom for their religion.
The Wakefields decided to flee, dismantling their press and moving it first to Charleston, until Charleston fell, and then to formerly Spanish East Florida. The war ended in British defeat, but for this family and many others the displacements and upheavals continued.
Next post: Unusual refugees
Liberty’s Exiles: American Loyalists in the Revolutionary World, Maya Jasanoff (2011) – my top resource for this part of the story
Dunmore’s New World, James Corbett David (2013) – I heard him give a talk during VA Festival of the Book just as I was finishing my story
The Traitor’s Wife (2014), Allison Pataki
The Tory Widow (2009), Christine Blevins
The Book of Negroes / Someone Knows My Name (2007), Lawrence Hill
Oliver Wiswell (1999), Kenneth Roberts
The King’s Rangers (1954), John Brick
With Nothing But Our Courage: The Loyalist Diary of Mary MacDonald (2002, young adult novel), Karleen Bradford
Sarah Bishop (1991, young adult novel), Scott O’Dell